Pottu wrote:Enjurbn wrote:Don't you understand what he meant? Really? It had nothing to do with you making profit, rather than with the Nostalrius project being illegal from the day 1 in the eyes of Blizzard, you knew damn well their stance on private servers when you started it, that they are against it.
The poster claimed that Nostalrius stole code from Blizzard. That is not true. As for the illegality of private servers, well, they are in a grey zone. Making a profit off of Blizzard's intellectual property is of course illegal and that has been confirmed in a US court. However, offering a gaming service that Blizzard does not offer, in a non-profit manner, has not been deemed illegal - to my knowledge - in any court of law. We wished to offer as authentic vanilla server as possible with our limited resources, to all players whether returners or new comers. We did not want to contest Blizzard's trademark or copyright in the first place and, aside from few exceptions, they have previously turned a blind eye towards non-profit private servers. I hope you can see the difference.
What i meant was, you guys (Nostalrius) were already using Blizzard's copyrighted content / game files so that is what i meant by "stolen code". It is illegal to use their "files" for personal use like making a private server without their agreement. And by double standards, yes, I meant exactly what other guy up said.
Having Illegal server in France is cool but relocating it to other country isn't? What kind of BS is that?
"We're respecting Blizzard" - kinda what admin said. - No you're not, at same day you took their content (files) / game to make a private server you "disrespected" them. (Like every other private server out there)