On a scale of 1 to erection how much better is Vanila > live

[Vaulken]

Erection all the way

[coldrex]

If a scale is from 1 - 10 (erection) i vote for something like this:

Tbc - erection
Wotlk - 6
MoP - 5
Vanila - 4
Cataclism - 4
WoD - 1

Even though I find that Vanila is certainly better then current exp,it just doesn't click with me... not my thing.I feel like it is too primitive in gameplay....outdated,unpolished,raw....

[Codeine]

vanilla - 10
tbc - 8
wotlk - 5
cata - 1
mop - 1
wod - -1

[Drain]

BC=best.
Wrath=2nd, depending on how much you hate heirlooms, dual specs, and the dungeon finder.
Everything after that is shit so Classic is where it's at.

[Mastodon2090]

Classic = erection
BC = dick so hard it could cut diamonds
Everything else = blue balls

[Robotron]

TBC > Vanilla > Wrath > everything else.

[gotmilk0112]

Live isn't *all* bad, it's just way too fucking easy, and way too streamlined. Way too much instant gratification. There's no feeling of satisfaction from working at something and then finally achieving it, you just get it super easily with no effort.

But yeah, like the others said, TBC is still king, with Vanilla and Wrath following behind it. The rest is meh.

[Robotron]

I enjoyed the first tier of Cata (the last retail patch I played), but apparently the game went to complete asshole after Firelands dropped. I guess I quit at a good time.

[Nowitzki41]

1. TBC
2. Vanilla

And idgaf about the rest

[kefran]

I enjoyed the first tier of Cata (the last retail patch I played), but apparently the game went to complete asshole after Firelands dropped. I guess I quit at a good time.

I agree with you, i like the start of Cata with the revamp of the old zones.

For me TBC was the best i played (I start to play wow in 2007 also...)