Prot warrior enchants

[Alipius]

while getting closer to complete my preraid BiS gear, im wondering what enchants should be used at the different itemts.
Does anybody have an overview of what enchants are best for which items for tanking?

[Undertanker]

Chest legs helm 100 hp. Gloves 7 agil. Bracer 9 stam, boots 7 stam. Shoulders +5 fire resist, cloak + armor or 3 agi. 7 stam shield. 1h crusader if it is slow. If you got a 1.3 weapon get +5 damage.

[vytiokas]

Chest legs helm 100 hp. Gloves 7 agil. Bracer 9 stam, boots 7 stam. Shoulders +5 fire resist, cloak + armor or 3 agi. 7 stam shield. 1h crusader if it is slow. If you got a 1.3 weapon get +5 damage.

Thank you

[St0rfan]

Chest legs helm 100 hp. Gloves 7 agil. Bracer 9 stam, boots 7 stam. Shoulders +5 fire resist, cloak + armor or 3 agi. 7 stam shield. 1h crusader if it is slow. If you got a 1.3 weapon get +5 damage.

Crusader procrate as it is right now isnt determined by PPM/Weapon speed so Crusader is a great choice even for a fast dagger. I use it on my alcors and get a 50-70% uptime.

[Undertanker]

Wasnt implying PPM. 1.3 speed with +5 is a 9.8% dps boost with 100 percent uptime. Slower weapons like Quel I have crusader because I use it in 5 mans because heroic strikes are few in between in a 5 man. Also bit white hits help get more initial rage which helps get that first sunder off sooner

[The Shortest Path]

Chest legs helm 100 hp. Gloves 7 agil. Bracer 9 stam, boots 7 stam. Shoulders +5 fire resist, cloak + armor or 3 agi. 7 stam shield. 1h crusader if it is slow. If you got a 1.3 weapon get +5 damage.

Crusader procrate as it is right now isnt determined by PPM/Weapon speed so Crusader is a great choice even for a fast dagger. I use it on my alcors and get a 50-70% uptime.

I thought that just got fixed?

[St0rfan]

Chest legs helm 100 hp. Gloves 7 agil. Bracer 9 stam, boots 7 stam. Shoulders +5 fire resist, cloak + armor or 3 agi. 7 stam shield. 1h crusader if it is slow. If you got a 1.3 weapon get +5 damage.

Crusader procrate as it is right now isnt determined by PPM/Weapon speed so Crusader is a great choice even for a fast dagger. I use it on my alcors and get a 50-70% uptime.

I thought that just got fixed?

Doesnt seem like it. I ran MC two days ago and had a PPM for 2.5-3 meaning an uptime of 50-75%. which translates into an average 50-75str bonus. To convert this into actual DPS that would be:

((((50+75)/2)*2)/14) = avg 8,928571428571429 DPS

This is a very rough estimate based on the PPM I got on that MC few days back and shouldnt be considered solid proof of anything.

EDIT: I would like to see how Undertanker determined that 5 weapon dmg increases DPS/TPS by 10%. Wouldnt the formula for 5 weapon dmg on (Alcors in this case) look like this:

(((41+77+5) / 2) / 1.3) = 47,30769230769231 DPS.

47.3-45.4 = 1.9 DPS increase.

45.4 / 47.3 = 0,959830866807611 = 4.1% DPS increase of the weapon

My math could be all bonkers so please correct it if anyone see errors.

EDIT: My conclusion is that crusader uptime would have to be 0.5 PPM in order for 5 weapon dmg to be better.

[Undertanker]

To do dps you have to add 5 to the min and max. So ((46+82)/1.3) /2 = 49.2 dps.

[St0rfan]

To do dps you have to add 5 to the min and max. So ((46+82)/1.3) /2 = 49.2 dps.

I'm pretty sure it doesnt work that way. Could someone else confirm or deny?

[Undertanker]

Why do you think it would only add 5 damage to your max hit, but leave lowest the same. If the lowest it can hit is 41, and hits 41 and i have +5 damage, my lowest hit will be 46.