Nostalrius Begins - Quality wow vanilla realm (1.12)

I recently got a hunter to level 10, charmed a boar, went off to tame a surf crawler, and my boar is gone and I cannot charm the surf crawler because it says I already own a charmed pet. I can't call the boar back and relogging does nothing. I abandoned the quest and picked it back up and the same thing happened. How do I fix this bug?

I am also experiencing this same issue, except when trying to tame the Armored Scorpid. Any help is appreciated!