Nostalrius Begins - Quality wow vanilla realm (1.12)

In my character ign "Maker" in the PVE server,

I recently completed the Warlock quest to get the item "Orb of Noh'Orahil".

However, upon selecting, I accidently got the orb that gives +Fire spells instead of +Shadow spell damage. I realized that this has to do with me choosing to collect the orb from the infernal instead of the felhunter. I had no idea that doing so would force me to get the +Fire spell orb off hand instead. I was wondering if there was any possible way to get the shadow orb instead of the fire orb at this point? Thanks guys

If you already received your reward (the fire orb) than you wont be able to switch them. You can abandon the quest and pick the one you want to go with though.

Nope you're SOL

Thanks for the replies guys, anyone know the next weapon/offhand/staff I should go for at this point?

really, anything with intelligence and spirit, or int and stam