Appreciate the call out, Lorilay!
In MC, I am usually always offtanking on Garr, Sulf, and Domo. I actually offtank even more in BWL, particularly on almost all trash pulls and on Broodlord (bear armor helps a ton with the MS) and even on Nef (to help with tanking on P1 and with constructs). I don't do any dps on Razorgore either b/c our guild uses druids to sleep dragons the entirety of phase one, so I wear MP5 gear that fight. These are the reasons why when you look at the average dps over the course of a full raid, I'll never come close to top pure dps classes. However, this could also be seen as an argument for the versatility a good feral druid can bring to a raid.
You can see all of my top DPS performances here: http://realmplayers.com/RaidStats/BossL ... r=Grayclaw
I'm still trying to get comfortable with all of the BWL fights (never raided BWL in retail :p), so I anticipate my dps numbers going up significantly once I get into a better flow on these fights.
Ultimately, I think feral druids get a bad rep b/c it is an extremely high skill cap spec to play. Nailing those powershift timings is very difficult, but it is a thing of beauty when you hit them all perfectly. Also, if you are a feral druid dpsing and you aren't using Wolfshead Helm, you are doing it wrong!