i'd reserve myself from the list because we will disagree on many items.
anyway there are many options . i'd rather go full paladin sets > offsets . only melee items i would focus are fingers,cloak,neck for agi and hit cap.
Intellect should be treated equal as str (we need both of them at same time on each piece of item we have).
more mana pool = more max ranks abilities spam = spam judge on cd = more dps and more procs .
agility full ench so we can max our crits.
just example of my theory how it suppose to look our retri pve gear : (take a look careful on itemwise)
http://realmplayers.com/CharacterViewer ... Killerdukitrinks i'd go for dmf/lbrs (if they exist) and strongest/slowest 2h weap (sulfuras very bis currently) .
The item wise will bring you enormous dps. (remember we are not warriors).
Evidence for the DPS on crappy bugged/nerfed server :
http://realmplayers.com/RaidStats/Fight ... ssLimit=Pa1 target non undead.
cheers by killerduki