Astixium wrote:I don't understand why you're getting all sassy over off-topic things and the thing that you don't seem to understand for some reason is that they are 3 different specs for 3 different things and none of them is a pure PvP spec, they are all for LEVELING, as the guy asked for a LEVELING spec and we both know that if you understand what you're doing while leveling you can get to 60 without a single kill. Also if you NEED shatter to be effective in BGs or world PvP you're clearly new on the whole mage thingy so you shouldn't write things that have nothing to do with the topic.
Have a nice day sir.
I don't think that he was really all that off topic. The topic is about a good leveling spec, and to my understanding, he was saying that when leveling on a pvp server, it is prudent to spec shatter. If anything, the raid spec that he was attacking is off topic, since the OP was asking about about a leveling spec and not a post-60 spec.
In any case, I agree that it's a wise move to spec shatter while leveling on this server. Do you *need* shatter to win in pvp? Not necessarily. You also don't necessarily *need* to wear gear to successfully pvp people as a mage, but it's still recommended.
Even if this was a pve server, I'd still spec shatter. Prior to level 60, shatter is infinitely more useful than Winter's Chill, so why would you need Winter's Chill in a leveling spec? Even at level 60 it might be wasted talent points, because only one mage per raid needs that talent.