Kamisayo wrote:Of course it's fair game if they just happen to buy the item at the low price - that is my own risk. What I mean is, if they have a program set up to buy it within fractions of a second, that is punishable, right?
Note the difference between an addon and a bot.
A bot, when we talk about wow, normally refers to a program running outside of WoW that controls game action. Those are subject to bans both on retail and here.
An addon, on the other hand, is using functions provided by Blizzard to interact with the game in a limitited way. (No movement, no spell casts without an associated keypress etc.) You were never banned for using an addon in vanilla and on this server the only time someone has been banned for an addon so far was when they used a function that the devs considered bugged, and even then they warned the players to stop before they went ahead and banned them.
While the stuff you can do with an addon in 1.12.1 is limited, both refreshing the AH, scan the AH, and buy items on the AH are included. This means that if I want to buy 20 Illusion Dust for an enchant, I can set an addon up to buy any Illusion Dust posted on the AH for under 80 silver, maximum 20 total, and go take a shower. No bot needed. On retail this would be 100% fine.
Nostalrius obviously isn't retail. And they can take any action they see fit. But if they wish to classify using certain addons as "not kosher" they really should specify what behavior they don't want players to do. If they don't like these snipers (for example because they look so much like 3rd party program bots that players assume that its ok to use such programs) they should make it forbidden but announce it in their ToU document and wait a few days before enforcing it. The rule could be as simple as.
"While the API allows for the creation of auction house "bots", the act of using such a script or addon for a period of time longer than a few seconds is considered a breach of the ToU and is subject to account action."
The reason that it "has" to be allowed for a few seconds is that otherwise popular and non-harmful addons like Aux would get caught in the crossfire.