Nostalrius Begins - Quality wow vanilla realm (1.12)

Currently doing the Cyclonian quest for the warrior weapon quest. I have all the quest items and it's checked as "completed" in my quest log. But when I go to turn it in to Bath'rah the Windwatcher it's greyed out. I've tried relogging. I've had this happen before and have simply dropped the quest and picked it back up and had it work. But if I drop this quest it destroys the essence of the exile.