Why TBC should be a separate server. (with Chars Copy).

In response to the Thread Named : Why TBC shouldn't be a separate server.
Quote of the Op :
>>> Best answer to the OP :
>>> And the best Idea that came across the Thread IMO :
This Idea is for me the Best.
It respects both worlds, keeps the vanilla community up, and only widen it for the BC Fanbase.
In my taste wow ended up after BC.
I would then love to have both, Vanilla and BC.
Lots of improvements on this great expansion especially on pvp.
That way, the choice of everyone is respected. Vanilla purists can enjoy Vanilla, BC purists enjoys BC.
And anyone can even play both versions. With character Copy. Without melting everything.
This idea for me would certainly not destruct the community but only improve it.
END.
Quote of the Op :
Draulius wrote:I am aware that there are plans to create a separate TBC server a long while after all content in Nostalrius Begins has been cleared. But that idea worries me, let me explain why...
By the time the TBC server is created I think people will be bored of Vanilla content. Most people will switch to the TBC server, and the community will split. Not only will it split, but the TBC server will mostly be high level characters due to the transfers, and that makes it discouraging to create a new character on the TBC server - therefore splitting the community further and punishing new players. And by time the TBC server is released, I believe the population will be much lower than what it is now, so a split then may be far more damaging than if it happened today. Transfers to an updated server are not Blizzlike, so these are the problems we face. The only possible solution to this I can think of is if transfers from Begins are always open rather than for a brief time, but I have an even better idea than that...
Basically, I am asking that the Nostalrius staff reconsider how they are going to handle the expansion, and instead upgrade Nostalrius Begins to TBC rather than opening up a whole new server. That also requires less maintenance on the staff team's part and is more Blizzlike. I don't think many people would be upset by this decision, since they have plenty of time to complete Vanilla content, and The Burning Crusade is a great expansion anyway.
>>> Best answer to the OP :
Sethzer wrote:There is a reason why they plan to have the TBC server on the side so people who want to go onwards to TBC can do that and those who want to remain on vanilla for whatever reason they have can do so.
You speak of being concerned about population etc. of TBC server since community might be split. Forcing those who wants to stay on with vanilla or those whom simply dislike TBC will make them leave Nostalrius alltogether and that's nothing but a loss for everyone and will give negative reputation on Nostalrius.
Also you are most likely forgetting people who love TBC but hate vanilla that ain't playing on Nostalrius now. There might be a huge flow of players coming to TBC Nostalrius from other projects once that goes live. Community and population on their future TBC server, that I doubt will come for atleast 2+ years, should be the least of the dev's concern right now.
And what of those who maybe joins this server late? They ding 60 and start gearing from 5man and then being told that vanilla time is over? Or those who are progressing late and have just finished BWL and are clearing in AQ40 but then 60 primetime is over because everyone will be forced to have a new maxlevel?
>>> And the best Idea that came across the Thread IMO :
Jackyy wrote:i like the idea of 2 diffent servers who stop progressing at the final tier raid of their expansion.
BUT
some kind of "chracter copy" would be nice, so u can "copy" your vanila char including gear and PvP ranks (excluding gold) to the TBC server.
so you still have the feeling of "progressing" through both expansions with the same char.
This Idea is for me the Best.
It respects both worlds, keeps the vanilla community up, and only widen it for the BC Fanbase.
In my taste wow ended up after BC.
I would then love to have both, Vanilla and BC.
Lots of improvements on this great expansion especially on pvp.
That way, the choice of everyone is respected. Vanilla purists can enjoy Vanilla, BC purists enjoys BC.
And anyone can even play both versions. With character Copy. Without melting everything.
This idea for me would certainly not destruct the community but only improve it.
END.