So I was raidleading a 50/50 guild/pug MC-run last night, and this rogue Ybiwashka ninjas Core Hound Tooth.
We told everyone when LFM that we would be doing a +1 with no resets, the +1 only counting on _contested_ items.
This guy had gotten 2 pieces of Nightslayer prior to this unfortunate situation, which these 2 links shows:
http://realmplayers.com/CharacterViewer ... =Ybiwashka
http://realmplayers.com/RaidStats/RaidO ... Raid=31824
The Nightslayer Chest being the only contested item, the gloves were sort of "free" in that matter.
As he rolled highest, he used that as his argument to loot the CHT, but everyone in the raid knew of our rule, as we had discussed it a few times on Teamspeak when a few pugging druids needed multiple items.
Anyway, this picture shows him taking the CHT, and the links above show him getting multiple items (which is quite alright if not the NS chest was been contested by another rogue).
http://imgur.com/ZKfASi3
PSA for our fellow Alliance players who does not want their loot to be taken injustice!