Nostalrius Begins - Quality wow vanilla realm (1.12)

Hi I'm a warrior specced in 5/5 mace that supposedly gives a 6% stun chance.
I thought it was peculiar that my Earthshaker mace stun effect occured much more than the actual talents in Arms, it really seemed a little off so I went ahead and tested it.

you can view the difference below.

My speculation is that the earthshaker stun chance is shared with the talent tree stun chance, so putting in the talents in the arms tree if you already have the earthshaker mace doesn't help. Could this be true?


Entity is afflicted by Earthshaker.
Your Earthshaker was resisted by Entity.
Entity is afflicted by Earthshaker.
Entity is afflicted by Mace Stun Effect.
Entity is afflicted by Earthshaker.
Entity is afflicted by Mace Stun Effect.
Entity is afflicted by Earthshaker.
Entity is afflicted by Earthshaker.
Entity is afflicted by Earthshaker.
Entity is afflicted by Earthshaker.
Entity is afflicted by Earthshaker.
Entity is afflicted by Earthshaker.
Entity is afflicted by Earthshaker.
Entity is afflicted by Earthshaker.
Entity is afflicted by Earthshaker.
Entity is afflicted by Earthshaker.
Entity is afflicted by Earthshaker.
Entity is afflicted by Earthshaker.
Entity is afflicted by Earthshaker.
Entity is afflicted by Earthshaker.
Entity is afflicted by Earthshaker.
Entity is afflicted by Earthshaker.
Entity is afflicted by Mace Stun Effect.
Entity is afflicted by Earthshaker.
Entity is afflicted by Earthshaker.
Entity is afflicted by Mace Stun Effect.
Entity is afflicted by Mace Stun Effect.
Entity is afflicted by Earthshaker.
Entity is afflicted by Earthshaker.
Entity is afflicted by Earthshaker.
Entity is afflicted by Earthshaker.
Entity is afflicted by Earthshaker.
Entity is afflicted by Earthshaker.
Entity is afflicted by Earthshaker.
Entity is afflicted by Earthshaker.
Entity is afflicted by Earthshaker.
Entity is afflicted by Earthshaker.
Entity is afflicted by Earthshaker.
Entity is afflicted by Earthshaker.
Entity is afflicted by Earthshaker.
Entity is afflicted by Earthshaker.
Entity is afflicted by Earthshaker.
Entity is afflicted by Earthshaker.
Entity is afflicted by Earthshaker.
Entity is afflicted by Earthshaker.
Entity is afflicted by Earthshaker.
Entity is afflicted by Earthshaker.
Entity is afflicted by Earthshaker.
Entity is afflicted by Earthshaker.
Entity is afflicted by Earthshaker.
Entity is afflicted by Earthshaker.
Entity is afflicted by Earthshaker.
Entity is afflicted by Earthshaker.
Entity is afflicted by Earthshaker.
Entity is afflicted by Earthshaker.
Entity is afflicted by Earthshaker.
Entity is afflicted by Mace Stun Effect.
Entity is afflicted by Earthshaker.

this should be enough sample size. 20-30 earthshaker stuns happened before a mace stun effect

so this lead me to believe that the mace stun effect doesnt work in arms tree, at least not while wielding the earthshaker.
because it took me around 15 normal hits in order to get a earthshaker stun, and at least 300 hits! before a mace stun proc occured.

It makes the earthshaker stand for 5% of the stuns and makes the talent tree stun chance stand for only 1% chance to stun but the talent tree says 6% chance. so it's lying.

I equipped a gray two-handed mace
and the mace effect stun came after 21 hits! wow I had a keen eye that something was wrong.


this can only be summarized as
the talent tree gives no extra chance to stun when u wield the earthshaker it only steals 1% of the earthshaker chance stuns and adds it to the total pool of stun chance allowed.
wasted talent points!

A heads up for all the earthshaker wielders out there, I know you are a few at least.

good mace that basically gives you 5 talent points for free. But where to spend them now?