Are DHK penalties working properly? Hmm

[Simonich]

Ive realised that the rank points lost are not distributed to the ones eligible for gaining a dhk in a group.

As far as i know, if there are 2 lvl 60s in a group that kill a civilian a 100 rank point penalty will be shared, meaning they will get 50 rank points reduced, if 4 are in group, each one will lose 25 rank points.

But right now, everyone loses 100 RP for being in the group which is wrong, as far as i know. Right now if 1 guy kills a civilian he loses 100 rank points. If 40 guys in a group kill a civilian they all lose 100 rank points.

Im not sure how its supposed to work, do you know anything about it?

[Simonich]

Bump, can someone please confirm? Dishonorable kills are currently overpunishing

[Rikkisix]

Orcs are all about honor last time i looked, could just be that you have failed your culture.

[postwarelephant]

Bump.

I would also like some clarification on how the DHK's work and how the penalty is shared out in a party.

Any player or GM able to chip in with how it works?

[Healthycoww]

But right now, everyone loses 100 RP for being in the group which is wrong, as far as i know. Right now if 1 guy kills a civilian he loses 100 rank points. If 40 guys in a group kill a civilian they all lose 100 rank points.

Correct. IIRC that's how it worked on retail too. Made city raids always a little bit dangerous because of it.

[Simonich]

But right now, everyone loses 100 RP for being in the group which is wrong, as far as i know. Right now if 1 guy kills a civilian he loses 100 rank points. If 40 guys in a group kill a civilian they all lose 100 rank points.

Correct. IIRC that's how it worked on retail too. Made city raids always a little bit dangerous because of it.

Thankfully stormwind and ironforge dont have any civilians, as if guards, long gy run and pvp protection wasnt enough